Join my community for regular insights via email -

Giving Feedback at the Right Time

Giving Feedback at the Right Time

Some years ago, I was sitting on a train opposite a couple. She was heading into her mid-year review, and when he asked how she thought it would go, she replied, “Well, I’ve not been told I’m crap lately.”

Her boss only ever gave feedback twice a year. They kept a little notebook for each person in the team, and everyone knew that whatever went in it would come out at the review.

In this final episode of my short series on giving feedback, I look at something that’s easy to overlook: timing.

The closer you share feedback to the moment you noticed it, the more useful it is.

Hold onto it, and three things happen.

Memories drift apart, the detail fades, and the delay itself sends a message about how much it really mattered.

But giving feedback at the right time isn’t just about speed.

I also share the one check I always encourage leaders to make first, so that what you say actually lands.

In this episode, you will learn:

  • Why saving feedback for the mid-year or annual review undermines its value
  • The three things that happen when you hold onto feedback
  • Why delayed feedback is easier to dismiss
  • Two reasons why “straight away” isn’t always the right time
  • A simple question to check someone is ready to hear what you have to say
  • How to give feedback professionally, at a moment that works for the other person

Ben’s Key Takeaways

Timing matters. When you sit on feedback, your recollections drift apart and the detail fades. You end up debating what happened instead of what to do about it.

Saving feedback up doesn’t make it land harder. It makes it easier to dismiss. If it really mattered, why didn’t you mention it at the time?

Sooner doesn’t mean instantly, though. Before giving feedback, consider two things: the other person’s emotional state, and what else is on their mind. Then ask, “Is now a good time for some quick thoughts on that?” If it isn’t, agree when it will be.

One thing to try this week: the next time you notice something worth sharing, don’t make a note for later. Check it’s a good time, and share it as soon as they’re ready to hear it.

A final thought:

Don’t save it up. Share it while it still matters, and when they’re ready to hear it.

Want to learn more about how to be a leader?

The next cohort of my ‘Leader in Me’ programme starts on 12 January 2027.

If you’re ready to:

  • Build confidence and capability as a leader
  • Break free from firefighting and become more proactive
  • Learn how to inspire your team and deliver results…

Learn more and book your people onto the programme here.

 

 

Podcast Transcript

Giving Feedback at the Right Time

Some years ago, I was sitting on a train opposite a couple. He asked her what she had on that day.

“My mid-year review,” she said.

“How do you think it’ll go?”

“Well, I’ve not been told I’m crap lately.”

She went on to explain that she and her colleagues never got any feedback from their boss, except twice a year.

Their boss kept a little notebook for each person in the team. Everyone knew it existed. And everyone knew that whatever went in it would come out at the review.

This is the final episode in this short series on feedback, and it’s about something that’s easy to overlook: timing.

The closer you share feedback to the moment you noticed it, the more useful it is. Hold onto it, and three things happen.

First, your recollections drift apart. By the time you raise it, you remember one version of events, and they remember another. Now you’re debating what happened instead of what to do about it.

Second, it fades. The detail that made it meaningful slips from the other person’s memory as time goes by.

And third, perhaps most importantly, it sends a message. If it really mattered, why didn’t you mention it at the time?

Saving feedback up doesn’t make it land harder. It makes it easier to dismiss.

But there’s one caveat, and it’s one I talk about a lot in my work: before you share feedback, check it’s a good time.

Imagine someone in your team has just had a presentation go badly. You want to talk to them about it. But there are two reasons why straight away might not be right.

The first is their emotional state. If they’re stressed or rattled, they’re not in a place to take anything on board.

The second is what else is on their mind. They might be about to ring their son or daughter’s school after two missed calls. If they’re worrying about something else, at home or at work, they won’t really be listening.

So ask, “Is now a good time for some quick thoughts on that presentation?” If it isn’t, agree when it will be.

So here’s one thing to try this week.

The next time you notice something worth sharing, don’t make a note for later. Check it’s a good time, and share it as soon as they’re ready to hear it.

That’s it for this episode.

As always, look after yourself, and look after those you have the privilege and responsibility to lead.

Until next time… lead on.

Two things you can do to say thank you for this free resource

Subscribe to ”The Ben Morton Leadership Podcast“ on your preferred podcast platform to help us grow the show and bring you more fantastic interviews with senior leader

Connect with me on LinkedIn for regular leadership tips and insights. Be sure to add a personal note with the request.

Connect with Ben